† Denotes simulated scores were used to build handicap
| Number | Team | Golfer | Handicap Index |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Fore Skins (Steve and Mike) | Steve Ricketts | 14.3N † |
| Mike "reverend" Petruzzelli | 5.1N † | ||
| 2 | Fritz and Glen | Fritz Gunther | 13.8N † |
| Glen Hallett | 14.9N † | ||
| 3 | Mike D and Jim I | Jim Ihnatiuk (Iggy) | 7.9N † |
| Michael Dooley | 8.7N † | ||
| 4 | Stogeys and Bogeys (Alex and Jesse) | Alex Fitch | 7N † |
| Jesse Fallesen | 4.7N † | ||
| 5 | Team 1 (Greg and Tim) | Gregory Gottermeier | 7.2N † |
| Timothy Reilley | 9.6N † | ||
| 6 | Team Joe and John | Joe Petracca | 12.9N † |
| John LaFave | 4.4N † | ||
| 7 | Team UIS (Kasey and Joe) | Joseph Latorre | 6.1N † |
| Kasey Cooper | 4.3N † | ||
| 8 | Temp Team name 3 (John and John) | John Hultz | 8N † |
| John Reina | 14N † | ||
| 9 | Temp Team Name 4 (Pete and Lori) | Pete Schaub | 9.7N |
| Lori Hosmer | 23.2N † | ||
| 10 | The Lost Pro-V (Tracy and John) | Tracy Lupinetti | 10.5N † |
| John McCabe | 8.4N † | ||
| 11 | The Putts Brothers (Fred and Paul) | Fred Rion | 13.6N † |
| Paul Schwartzman | 15.1N † | ||
| 12 | Two Hand Hammer (Matt and Mike) | Matt Hammersmith | 1.7N † |
| Mike Munski | 5N † | ||
| 1 | Regular Substitute | Sub 6 | 0N |
| 2 | Regular Substitute | Fake Sub 1 (do not select this sub) | 1.4N |
| 3 | Regular Substitute | Fake Sub 2 | 2.5N |
| 4 | Regular Substitute | Fake sub 3 | 2.8N |
| 5 | Regular Substitute | fake sub 4 | 2N |